You may recall that recently I posted an article about the late Eva Braun, wife of Adolf Hitler and questioned whether she was the villain that some portray her as or was she merely a young girl looking for love, who was groomed by an older more powerful man.
Interestingly, a comment he is reputed to have made fits with this assumption
“A highly intelligent man should always choose a primitive and stupid woman,”
This blog is not about Ms Braun, it is about a woman who came before her, although there was some crossover in their place in Hitler’s circle as he is documented as having met Braun in 1929 when she was 17 years old, at the time he was sharing his Munich apartment with his 19yr old half niece, Angela (Geli) Raubal.
Geli was an integral part of Hitler’s life from the age of 17 when she, her mother and her sister moved into his Berghof Villa, her mother Angela taking on the role as her half brother’s housekeeper. It was a mere two years later that Geli moved to Munich, ostensibly to study medicine and was given a room in her Uncles grand property. There is much speculation as to the nature of their relationship, were they lovers? Did he wish they were lovers? Or was she merely a femme fatale capable of playing men to whichever tune she wished.
She is described as being tall, and beguiling, causing people to stop in the street to look at her. Having seen photos of her I would not describe her as beautiful, but there was something about her that caused Hitler to be incredibly jealous and possessive, and is reported to have flown into an almighty rage when he discovered she was in a physical relationship with his chauffeur. The lover was dismissed from his service – although by all accounts, not killed – and Geli had a chaperone with her every time she left the apartment.
There were many rumours at the time that Hitler and his niece were in a relationship, she is meant to have confided in his political rival, Otto Strausser, and shown him naked pictures of her drawn by Hitler that she was forced to pose for. There were also mutterings that she was pregnant and that Hitler had approached the Pope for dispensation to marry (not that unions between relatives were anything unusual for the family, he after all was the result of a marriage of two cousins, a strange one at that, his mother Klara was quite a bit younger than his father Alois and weirdly called him “Uncle”)
Whether Geli was Hitler’s plaything or whether he was just being an overprotective Uncle we will never know, but in September 1931, when he had left Munich to go on some political rally, Geli shot herself with Hitler’s personal pistol. What was strange about this suicide – and yes, after an investigation it was classed as such – was that the shot was not through her head like most gunshot suicides, but through her chest, as though she had tried to shoot her heart.
All seems cut and dried yes? She was uncomfortable with her life and killed herself, well, maybe not. The Nazi party was starting to feel a little bit uneasy with the amount of power this young woman had over their leader, after all, she is reported to have been capable of pulling him away from an important meeting if she wanted to do something as trivial as go swimming.
Upon hearing of her death, her uncle/lover was bereft, going so far as to hold a pistol to his own head and have it wrestled away by his deputy, Rudolf Hess.
Are these the actions of a murderer or a man overcome by grief? Or was someone else responsible for her death.
A local journalist, Fritz Gerlich, who had a vehement hatred of Hitler and his actions made it his mission to investigate and try and prove that if not Hitler personally, one of his minions was responsible for Geli’s death. Gerlich was arrested and executed in Dachau in July 1934, shortly after the Night of the long Knives (where Hitler and his cronies murdered anyone they deemed a threat) Was Gerlich murdered because he was getting too close to the truth? We will never know. The person that Geli had confided in, Otto Strasser, he was kicked out of the Nazi party in 1930 and after his brother was killed in the Night of the long Knives, fled into exile. You could argue that he was only spreading these “rumours” about the fuhrer’s depravity due to dislike and bitterness, again, we have no proof either way.
What is my conclusion, I am no Psychologist, but I find it interesting that his mother was much younger than his father and had an almost patriarchal relationship with her husband. I also believe that Hitler felt less powerful around women who were his “equal” and therefore tended to steer towards the younger “stupid” ladies (his words, not mine). I cannot decide as to whether Geli was murdered or if she simply realised, she was in far beyond her capabilities and knew Uncle Alfie would not let her go. I do think Geli was a naïve girl who saw the opportunity to be something special and did not fully realise (as most young adults don’t!) that if you make a deal with the devil, there are always consequences.
Tell me your thoughts…